Searching for the Best Web Analytics Software

- Lauren

Yesterday (7/22/08) was an eventful day for us. Roy Russo, the CEO of LoopFuse, took offense to my review and decided to address it by launching an adorable DOS attack. Though it wasn’t effective, it still shocked us so much that last night we decided it must not be Roy Russo at all, but someone with a vendetta trying to scapegoat him. As a result, we unapproved the comments until we could confirm it was him.

Well, we called him and he confirmed it. The comments below are really from Roy Russo. I know, we couldn’t believe it either. Check out our account of the LoopFuse incident.

To monitor the success of your SEO and internet marketing efforts, having a web analytics program is essential. Below I review four programs that I spent a month (each) testing for usability and functionality.

I’m not getting any kind of kickback for reviewing these web analytics programs (nor are the links here paid referral links). All of the programs reviewed here have free trial periods, so try them yourself and let me know what you think!

LoopFuse

LoopFuse offers more functionality than I ended up using. I didn’t integrate our CRM program. We don’t have registered users, so I didn’t set up registered user tracking.

That being said, there are certain features that every analytics program should offer easy access to. A basic “recent visitors” view with company/ISP name, location, referrer, operating system, browser, number of page visits, etc. is essential. LoopFuse doesn’t provide access to this information in one place. If you want to see visits listed by company name, for instance, you have to choose that view and you can’t access any of the other relevant information. Talk about making my job harder!

The interface is the least intuitive of everything I tried. The drop-down menus are small and difficult to use (the menus are 3-4 clicks deep, and one false click means starting over… so many wasted clicks). You can’t view the clickstream for visitors either, only their entry and exit pages.

Price: $300 a month for their “self-serve” package.

Trial Period: 15 days.

Final Impressions: the advanced functionality that LoopFuse offers may be great, but the basic functionality is counter-intuitive. It’s like a Thai restaurant that makes terrible pahd thai. Would you really want to try their attempt at salmon pahd king?

Hitslink

Hitslink, though clunky, does offer more convenient access to the visitor information I mentioned above. You can view the visit time, location, organization/ISP and referrer from recent visitors. To view details like OS and browser, you can click on a link that pops up a new window. To see an individual users page views, you have to click on a link that navigates you away from the recent visitors page. Not ideal, but at least the information is freely available.

Price: Starts at $9.95 a month, but that package would only be viable if you have less than 10 visitors a day (and those visitors only visit three pages). If you get 100-200 visitors a day, you’d be looking at paying $29.99 a month.

Trial Period: 30 days.

Final Impressions: The text is too small, making the data more difficult to process. The interface is clunky and not the most aesthetically pleasing. But it did have all the features I was looking for.

Opentracker

Opentracker is a solid website analytics program. The recent visitors view shows users that are currently active on the site, idle users, and offline users via green, yellow and red person icons respectively. Looking at user details is simple–just mouse over the person icon. A simple clickstream view shows the visitor’s page views and time spent on a given page.

Price: $19.95 a month will cover any website with less than 500 visitors a day.

Trial Period: 28 days.

Final Impressions: Opentracker is pretty intuitive. It was the first website analytics program I tried, and I was pining away for it. That is, until I tried…

Clicky

Oh, Clicky. You are truly the best website analytics program I can find. The dashboard view is completely customizable. You can add widgets and rearrange them based on your own user preferences. None of the other programs I reviewed had this functionality.

From my personalized dashboard, I can easily see an overview of the day’s traffic, including:

  • Daily most popular pages and downloads
  • Daily visitor locations
  • Daily traffic sources
  • Daily searches
  • Daily top referral links
  • Monthly visitor and page view charts

The interface is clean, readable and very easy to use. One of my favorite features, Spy, shows you website page views in real time. I often leave it up all day, glancing at it every hour or so. Clicky also has iGoogle and Netvibes plugins so you can watch your traffic from your customized homepage.

Powerful naming and filtering functionality allows you to gain an even deeper understanding of user behavior on your website.

Price: $9.99 a month will serve a site with up to 5000 visitors a day.

Trial Period: 21 days.

Final Impressions: By far the best analytics program, it also happens to be the cheapest of all those I reviewed. I fully recommend trying it out.

So, what’s your favorite web analytics program? If I’m missing an outstanding program, I’d love to check it out.

Bookmark and Share

Comments (32) Trackbacks (1)
  1. Roy Russo


    LoopFuse is a Marketing Automation Suite, NOT a web analytics package. Hence the price, hence the "extra functionality".

    ... and you can view the click-stream. Trial's are free, brain-cells aren't.

    Thanks for the plug, though. ;-)
  2. lauren


    I appreciate you proving my point about the customer service. I actually sent in a question asking about how to view clickthroughs, but surprise, no response, so I assumed the functionality didn’t exist. It obviously isn’t easy to find–I guess it’s just another example of the unintuitive interface. Glad to see your team is prompt about insulting reviewers, at least.

    I also understand that it's not just a web analytics program (pointed that out in the blog post). However, web analytics is listed as one of the products in your software suite, right there on your homepage.

    (btw, I had already nofollowed the link to your product, as I can’t endorse it, so the only plug you’re getting is from this post, where everyone will see your rude response. Cheers.)
  3. Ray Towle


    Lauren,

    I have no idea if "pahd thai" is intuitive; if "terrible pahd thai" is counter-intuitive, or if "salmon pahd king" is extra-intuitive; but I do know that on your way from the perplexing idiomatic expression, through the Thai restaurant analogy, to some stretch toward a metaphor of note . . . you simply lost me.

    See ya round the coffee shop!

    Ray
  4. lauren


    Hey Ray :)

    I see that you link to Loopfuse on your LinkedIn account. To be specific, the anchor text is: "A family business: LoopFuse." I don't see any actual work history for you with the company.

    So then, does someone in your family own LoopFuse, or is it just a friend of yours?

    Let me explain the Thai metaphor directly. If one piece of a software suite is unintuitive and limited, chances are the rest of the suite is also lackluster.
  5. Roy Russo


    Ray is an honorary member of the LoopFuse Executive Team, and I believe he's up for the OneView FellowShip Award. He's been instrumental in attending the company BBQs and sliding down the 20-foot-tall slip-n-slide, head-first. (Unfortunately, some of the little ones get in the way from time to time.)

    Lauren, is there any way I can have you post more blogs about LoopFuse? To-date, all the lead generation we've received from this blog has been exceptional.

    Shall I put you in contact with our Marketing Director?
  6. lauren


    It's funny that you ask! I was already planning on using LoopFuse (and you, of course, as the founder) as an example of how NOT to handle your online PR.

    No need to put me in touch with your Marketing Director unless she also handles your public relations. But my guess is you don't have much of a staff in that department?
  7. Roy Russo


    "But my guess is you don’t have much of a staff in that department?"

    They're all out back eating BBQ ribs.
  8. Slovenian Designer


    Roy Russo, you haven't a clue at what you're rude comments have started do you? Lauren, ignore this asshole, he's a loser and has no class at all, great reviews! Bookmarked this blog! (great design too!)
  9. Roy Russo


    Can you please get your little webmaster friend to blog more about us? Frankly, Michael Kane has led to us printing money!
  10. Slovenian Designer


    Roy, nice move. Now I think the ball is in MK's court.
  11. lauren


    Roy. Seriously. You just attempted a DOS attack on our blog. This is an article about web analytics, and we are a web dev/marketing company. You think we don't know how to cross-reference your IP?

    Could you be handling this any worse? Behave yourself, you're supposed to be the CEO of a company.
  12. Roy Russo


    The LoopFuse Marketing and Sales Automation platform auto-cross-references IP addresses for you - Resolving IPs to companies... a major benefit for Sales and Marketing professionals wanting better insight in to their visitors and prospects.
  13. Sam


    Getclicky has an awesome feature that lets you label and track visitors as they're browsing your site. Wordpress also happens to record the IP when a comment is posted.

    It makes cross referencing poorly executed blog comment attacks child's play, I can't really see needing an application to do that kind of work for me...
  14. Roy Russo


    Apples/Oranges... but LoopFuse does also allow you to "flag" or add, not only visitors, but entire companies to watch lists... thereby you're alerted when we observe any trackable activity (visit, email open, email click, lead capture, etc...).

    You may not see that as valuable, but mid-to-large B2B and B2C companies, surely need that information to improve marketing and sales effectiveness.
  15. lauren


    Come on. Think, Roy. You know what's on the minds of most large companies? Reliability, security.

    What do you think they'll make of you, personally, using a bot to attack a blog over a bad review? Perhaps that you're a *wee* bit unstable?

    I know to check up on a company before I utilize its products or services. You think other business owners don't do the same?
  16. Roy Russo


    You're right Lauren, can we be friends now? ;-)

    Ok, so that's not sarcasm... I'm just tired of the endless chatter with Michael. I can't believe the guy doesn't like gardening. Perhaps he likes plumbing?
  17. lauren


    Are you drunk?
  18. Roy Russo


    Honestly, I don't drink. I don't smoke, either. I'm an all-around boring guy. ;-)
  19. Slovenian Designer


    So you said sorry? Well smart move roy. It's a lot of trouble to get into over silly words and script kiddie like failed attempts. Glad this did not get too bad :)
  20. lauren


    Actually, I'm still waiting for that apology.
  21. Slovenian Designer


    You’re right Lauren, can we be friends now? ;-)



    ^ i thought that was it, maybe it's my english skills LOL
  22. Roy Russo


    Do you want me to mail you a box of flowers, too Lauren? :-)
  23. lauren


    @21: Nah, he was just acknowledging how mentally unstable all of this makes him seem.
  24. Slovenian Designer


    Well that's not good is it. Oh well.
  25. Roy Russo


    It was, but Lauren is now confusing my sarcasm and honesty. Clearly, this little comment-box is not a good conveyor of meaning/emotion.
  26. Slovenian Designer


    I don't thnk it's the comment box with issues, but glad all is resolved!
  27. Roy Russo


    Well... it could be my improper use of ;-), which I believe may have started the whole thing. ;-)
  28. Bryan Swift


    did you look at Mint (http://www.haveamint.com/)? I'm not affiliated with it and don't use it but I've heard good things about it and so I was just curious.
  29. lauren


    I hadn't seen Mint before, but I just spent some time exploring the features and demo and it looks promising.

    It's beautiful, for a start, and seems to have a good base of plug-ins (called Pepper).

    <a href="http://haveamint.com" rel="nofollow">Mint</a> has a couple of features that Clicky doesn't.

    For one, Mint allows you to break down page views and referrers by hour increments (e.g. last hour, 2hr, 4hr).

    The Doorbell Pepper makes a sound when new visitors arrive on site or when a visitor views a new page. This appeals to me, and might consume slightly less time than having to manually check every time I am curious about who's visiting.

    On the flip side, there aren't any iGoogle or NetVibes widgets in Mint (these are available in Clicky), and I don't see any way to assign a custom name to an IP.

    Mint doesn't have a free trial, but a license is only $30 (no subscription fees). It's definitely worth checking out.
  30. Bryan Swift


    If you decide to try it out I'd be interested to hear what you had to say about it. As you said the feature list is pretty nice and it does look quite beautiful but since I don't have much need to monitor my traffic too closely just now I'm not too interested in spending money when I can get google analytics for free. :)
  31. Bob Green


    One word: <a href="http://woopra.com" rel="nofollow">Woopra</a>.

    Enjoy,

    Bob
  32. lauren


    I look forward to checking out Woopra. There appears to be a waiting list--we're still waiting to be accepted. I'll be sure to post a review after we try it out.


Leave a Reply